L’émouvante Tosca de l'Opéra de Lille, Bachtrack

By  Stephane Lelièvre

 

Instead of a simple concert version, the Opéra de Lille chose Olivier Fredj for the video-compatible semi stage version. Olivier Fredj did the job in record time with what must have been limited means and the result is coherent and convincing. In his vision of this opera, transposed to the 20th and 21st century, with no reference to any specific historic context however, Scarpa appears to be much more than a mere chief of police. One can easily picture him holding forth at the crowds, which is suggested by the rostrum and the microphone in front of the empty chairs in the second act – and especially the projection of texts signed by him, as he tries to win the people over to a totalitarian and deadly ideology a final phrase (‘Virtù e merito’) in the tradition of Mussolini’s ideology.

The performance begins at dawn, with the execution of Palmieri (a character mentioned by Scarpa and Spoletta in the second act) to the applause of the crowd and ends as it should with the death of both Tosca and Marion twenty four hours later.

The time the events are supposed to occur is shown regularly at the back of the stage and this is justified as it contributes to having the action take place in a stifling unity of time, during which no fewer than five murders are to take place. The semi-stage version concentrates on the play of the singers (all excellent actors as it happens) and allows the perfectly well-oiled mechanics of the drama imagined by Sardou, Illica, and Giacosa to cast the net that will inevitably lead the main protagonists to their ruin.

The Armenian baryton, Gevorg Hakobyan, gives us a portrait of Scarpa based on insinuation and psychological torture more than explicit violence, which is even more terrifying.

There were only a few guests in the audience (namely the Town Mayor and Jean-Claude Casadeus) and a handful of journalists: the extensive bravos that resounded when the curtain fell testified to the quality of the performance and the wonderful emotion it created. The opera is to be found on the YouTube channel of the Opera de Lille.

 

Love is Loud: Tosca from the Opéra de Lille,  Opera Traveller

​

Olivier Fredj was credited as the director of a mise-en-espace, but what Fredj gave us was so much more than that.  This was a fully lived-in staging, using some minimal props and the full depth and width of the stage to create an evening of exciting theater.  The evening opened with shots of the chorus taking their distanced seats in the balcony and a man being actually shot in an execution on stage.  In doing so, Fredj immediately established the idea of a Scarpia-supporting crowd watching the action.  While we didn't get a full portrait of the Attavanti as the Madonna, we did have Cavaradossi's sketch pad upon which he drew her.  

​

Even within the limited environment, Fredj created some memorable stage pictures, not least in Act 3 with spotlights ranged along the stage, reinforcing the idea of Cavaradossi's 'fake' execution, and while there was no leap from the battlements, what Fredj gave us was equally convincing, leaving us with a sense that all that happened to the three protagonists was completely inevitable.  It helped also that he had a pair of highly charismatic lovers in Joyce El-Khoury and Jonathan Tetelman.  There was a genuine chemistry between them - particularly in the way that Tetelman's Cavaradossi whispered instructions to El-Khoury's Tosca not to betray him in Act 2, or Tetelman's visible disbelief that the execution was fake but his desperation to give Tosca some comfort in the moment .  Given the sanitary restrictions that made this production necessary, Fredj has made so much of little and given us an evening of high drama and gripping theater.

​

Tosca poignardant l'épidémie,  Forum Opéra
By  Camille De Rijck  

​

There are evenings like this when opera seems simple: take a few good singers, an orchestra at its best, an energetic conductor, a dignified sparing mise en espace and if it weren’t for the theatre itself that was three quarters empty, the experience would be exquisite. Olivier Fredj’s mise en espace which was planned for a video capsule, is a model of its kind: traditional without being didalistic, modern without being grating, merely concentrating on the actors on this vast empty stage in an elegant setting. 

 

 

La mariée était en noir,  Wander

​

The brutality of the action and the political dimension of the opera are underlined in an explicitly heavy sombre atmosphere, highlighting Scarpia’s secret police who obey the power of the monarchy and the internal struggles that occur day after day in the short-lived Roman Republic.

 

 

OPERA ONLINE

Thibault Vicq

 

It is at  Olivier Fredj  that falls the responsibility of a setting in space, after its diptych of belcanto  The King and His Favorite  /  The Queen and Her Favorite  at the Monnaie de Bruxelles last March. The excess of frills does not suit Tosca, on the other hand, it takes a concern for the effectiveness of the drama. There, everything is there, in costumes, by looks, with chairs lit with unreal rays between life and death. The relentless race of time in the face of events - characteristic of the play - results in the display of a timetable at each stage. The death of Scarpia and the shooting of Cavaradossi are two of them and two highlights of which the Choir of the Lille Opera, installed in a basket like spectators in performance, does not miss a beat. The show should also be revealed in a different light during its digital broadcast, edited as in the cinema and without an intermission. This theatrical language of the essential, mixed with the incredible synthetic substance of music, is sure to work!

 

OLYRIX

By Fantine Douilly

​

The needs of capture coupled with those of sanitary distancing justify a very particular room configuration with an orchestra coming out of its pit to occupy the floor, and the  Choir of the Lille Opera  on the balcony. This arrangement is as much a health advantage, an acoustic diffusion and spatialization as the contribution of an immersive dimension to certain scenes. The Te Deum closing Act I with the thundering horns at the height of the hall is thus of the most striking effect and transforms the wall of the pit to be crossed traditionally into a sound universe reinforcing the lyrical projections.

 

Unable to adapt the staging of  Robert Carsen  initially planned, the staging amounts to  Olivier Fredj  who knew how to cope with the constraints. The entire room becomes the place of action by offering a stripped-down universe, translating the staging of power offered by the libretto (religious rites, balance of power and execution). The strength of this proposal is to offer a larger space of expression to the artists by giving pride of place to bodily engagement even in its most subtle manifestations (games of glances, muscular tensions). The viewer will also appreciate the work of highlighting  Nathalie Perrier  “Facing the nudity of a theater set defined in space as in emotion by the lights” (contextualize  Olivier Fredj ). Subtle and constantly negotiated, they are enough to transport from the Château Saint Ange to the semi-darkness of the jail where Mario lives his last moments.

​

FIRST LODGES

through  Gilles Charlassier 

If the constraints of the epidemic can be seen in the adaptation of the pit, moved to the pit to leave the musicians the space necessary for the protocols, they can also be read in the scenic show. Since Robert Carsen's production cannot be presented with the current restrictions, Caroline Sonrier and the Lille Opera have entrusted Olivier Fredj with a new staging. With the complicity of the very cinematographic lights of Nathalie Perrier, the Frenchman takes advantage of the nudity of the stage, barely furnished with a few chairs to symbolize a corner of a church nave or the apartments of Scarpia, and a few video projections - we will remember essentially the face of Tosca which, in black and white, punctuates the drama, in particular at each end of the act. The distribution of the choirs on the first balcony overflows the stage from its frame and accentuates the theatricality of their interventions, in the air of crowd commentary - almost a device of Passion. The texts on the curtain are given like lines taken from Scarpia's memoirs, be they posthumous or apocryphal, and deliver the point of view of the sadistic baron, by explaining certain tragic ellipses, like the execution of Count Palmieri , allegedly simulated when it was live ammunition, as later, that of Cavaradossi. The digital clock reproduced at each start of the sequence underlines a unit of time in emergency mode. As for the knot with which Tosca hangs himself at the end, it refers to the ordeal that was to be that of Mario Cavaradossi - before Scarpia preferred the ambiguity of the shooting. In short, cinematographic minimalism does not preclude a few dramaturgical comments, sometimes welcome, for the neophyte first.